Speaking For The Trees
In this week’s newsletter, we check on the state of Ocean Avenue's urban canopy and more.
It was unclear whether the names put forth by community members are being considered.
Community members who spoke to The Ingleside Light said they were unimpressed by the overwhelmingly non-native plant names proposed for the lanes of the upcoming Balboa Reservoir housing development.
“Those are like generic names that somebody might use in a subdivision out in Contra Costa County,” Ingleside resident Sam Darby said of the development team’s entries. “I’d much rather see the streets names for people or landmarks or something like that unique to San Francisco.”
At the Sept. 10 open house at Unity Plaza, the developers held a vote for attendees to name three lanes of the project, proposing eight plants and one type of plant as candidates: Buckeye, Currant, Evergreen, Ginkgo, Loquat, Meyer, Mulberry, Pear and Wisteria.
Only two names — the Buckeye and Currant — are of native plants, said Malcolm Hillan, a 22-year environmental horticulture instructor at City College of San Francisco and a licensed landscape contractor.
The names were of plants “programmed” for the development, Jeff Breidenbach, a principal at Argus Design who worked on the project’s branding, told The Ingleside Light at the open house.
The plant list for the development is still being coordinated in real time and is not yet solidified, said Gary Strang, principal at GLS San Francisco.
Breidenbach also said that the names came from “the idea of growth and vitality.”
However, interviewees in the surrounding neighborhoods said the entries seemed dull and preferred names with local significance — with most suggesting a reference to Indigenous tribes in the area.
At the open house, attendees hand-wrote their own entries next to the development team’s proposals. Breidenback had said that he thought the publicly written names wouldn't be chosen, but Nora Collins, a senior director of development at AvalonBay Communities, had told The Ingleside Light all names would be considered.
"We appreciate the community's interest in potential names; we'll look at the votes and see," Collins said.
Sunnyside resident J. Heggie said the suggestions were relatively safe, being “plants rather than people’s names.”
Heggie added that she was glad to see someone propose the name “Diego,” as it could help guide people to the planned Diego Rivera Theater.
However, it’s been nearly three weeks, and no one updated the online poll to include the community’s handwritten entries. Balboa Reservoir developers did not respond to a request for an update on the vote results or for an explanation on how the community’s handwritten entries will be considered if they’re not included in the online poll.
Community members proposed Edwin Lee Avenue, Reverend “G” Gordon Lane, Diego Lane, Reservoir Lane and Phelan — names with local significance.
Ingleside resident Steven Brown suggested using names that memorialized the original stewards of the land, the Ramaytush Ohlone.
Westwood Park resident Paul Yamazaki said he’d prefer to have street names that weren’t “so generic” as the plant names.
He suggested using the names of native plants, Indigenous people who had lived in the area or notable graduates at City College of San Francisco, or some combination of the three.
“It’s like you’re in the suburbs or something if you have Loquat Street or something,” Yamazaki said.
Westwood Park resident Angel Islas echoed the others’ feelings about including Indigenous people’s names to reflect that residents are living on “the unceded lands of the native peoples of San Francisco.”
“I would say the names were acceptable but uninspiring,” Islas said. “It would be a really good idea to reflect some names that haven’t been represented in the past and something that would reflect the diversity and unique history of San Francisco.”
This story you’ve just finished was funded by our readers. We want it to inspire you to either sign up to become a member or make a gift to The Ingleside Light so that we can continue publishing stories like this one that matter to our community and city.
The Ingleside Light is a reader-funded news publication that produces independent journalism to benefit the community. We were founded in 2008 to fill a void in San Francisco’s press: An outlet dedicated to the people of the greater Ingleside neighborhood. More than a decade later, The Ingleside Light is still here doing the work because it is critical to democracy and our civic life.
Your contribution today will help ensure that our critical work continues. From development to small business, to parks and transportation and much more, we are busier than ever covering stories you won’t see anywhere else. Make your gift of any amount today and join the hundreds of readers just like you standing up for the power of independent news. Thank you.
We’ll send you our must-read newsletter featuring top news, events and more each Thursday.